What are traditional churches
shrinking?So why
are traditional liturgical Lutheran churches like Immanuel shrinking? Why
are fewer and fewer people attending church? Why are those who belong to a
church attending less often? And is there anything to be done about it? The
simple and most direct answer takes us to the First Table of the Law,
especially to the First and Third Commandments: You shall have no other
gods before Me and Remember the Sabbath Day to keep it holy.
But clearly more and more church members find breaking these Commandments
(not to mention a few others) easier than ever before and do so with little
or no guilt. But how did this come about? Why is it so easy for people to
neglect both worship and the teachings of Jesus?
The answer to these questions is twofold. One answer places the blame
squarely on the church, the leaders and laity in the 20th century
who failed to understand the cultural shift taking place before them and for
allowing secular pagan philosophies to infiltrate the church’s doctrine,
practice, and worship. The church and most Christian families are now
reaping what they sowed. In next month’s newsletter I will discuss these
more thoroughly.
The balance of this article is to address the second reason for declining
church attendance. So why are traditional churches like Immanuel shrinking?
Why, despite years of sermons, articles, warnings, and admonitions is
Immanuel contining to die as a congregation? The answer is simple. The
people of the Lutheran Church are immersed in the American culture. So on
"any given Sunday" the proper worship of God the Father, God the Son, and
God the Holy Spirit is up against:
*Sports Activities - - America is obsessed with sports. In days gone
by Wednesdays and Sundays (especially Sundays) were reserved for church and
religious instructions. In so doing our culture, include the sports
subculture, recognized the need and value of worship and religious
instruction in the life of a young person. But today, games, tournaments,
and even practices are placed in direct competition with worship and church
activities. Add to this the financial pressures of college and the "need" to
obtain athletic scholarships pushes the family even further away from
church. In this clash between the sports culture and the Christian culture,
nine times out of ten the sports culture wins. That’s why you don’t see many
families in church week in and week out. And before you know it, you don’t
see them in church at all.
*An Entertainment Culture - Ancient Rome was
held together in large part by their love of the gladiatorial "games" and
entertainment. Americans love recreation and entertainment. Many religious
social scientists have tapped into this and have turned churches in general
and the worship service in particular into a recreation and entertainment
event, thus changing people’s fundamental understanding and expectation of a
church and what worship is all about. So here too we see a clash of
cultures. Proper Christian worship is done in reverence, beauty, humility,
and joy (not "excitement"). But the people have been taught that they should
be entertained. When these two cultures clash, nine times out of ten the
traditional liturgical church loses.
Of course another big problem is the clash between worshiping, serving,
and helping out at the church and weekend recreating or some other
entertaining event. Again the church loses this contest far more than it
wins.
*A Consumer Culture - For more than 100 years, our public education
system has taught us to think in terms of producers and consumers. Americans
like choices. They believe they are entitled to it. We pay our money and we
should get a litany of goods and services. So also in the church. While
Christians should donate money to the church for the purpose of sharing with
their pastor the gifts God has given to them and for the purpose of paying
the bills and serving one’s neighbor, people donate more money when they get
the kinds of goods and services they want. So bigger churches offer a
smorgasbord of programs, support groups, and activities to fit a wide range
of ages, circumstances, and tastes. The smaller church cannot do the same.
So again, the traditional liturgical church, with its right understanding of
the nature and purpose of the church, will lose this contest too, at least
as the world judges winning and losing.
*A Culture of Skepticism, Subjectivism, and Post-Modernism - The
Christian religion is a religion of truth. If the belief in knowable truth
falls the Christian faith follows. God speaks and acts in history through
the prophets and apostles, and supremely through His Son Jesus Christ. He is
clear and His words mean what they mean. But our culture teaches that
everything is a matter of interpretation. No one is right. No one set of
doctrines is better or above another. And that everyone decides for himself
or herself what is right for them. We have become skeptics in regard to the
truth of God’s Word. So churches that still hold to true truth and pastors
who think they are right and those who disagree (speaking here of Articles
of Faith and morality) are to be avoided. Liturgical churches and
confessional pastors are never in vogue.
*Disrespect of Authority - We have lived in a culture of rebellion
for more than four decades now. People think nothing of thumbing their noses
at police, judges, and school teachers. Modern parenting has taught children
how to run the household. Even more so in the church. The disrespect and
rebellion has reached a high point in the church. Some of you may remember
the days when the Pastor and Elders/Deacons were held in honor and were
accorded a proper level of fear. Their judgments and leadership were also
trusted to a greater degree than we see today.
So when a pastor and lay leaders come along who act as leaders, judging
things according to a theological understanding, a challenge is likely to
follow and so after than a departure from a liturgical theological
congregation.
Congregations that believe their fundamental job is to
appease as many as possible and to let everyone do what is right in their
own eyes, seem to be fuller than the traditional liturgical churches.
*Affluence, Materialism, and Mobility - Even though we tend not to
think so, we are a very affluent culture. We tend to judge ourselves by how
much we have and how much we can do. Our standard of living today enables
people to eat out regularly, take a lot of time off to go places and do
things, and to live in a variety of social contexts. In days gone by the
church and church activities were the center of spiritual and social life.
But now there is competition everywhere and nine times out of ten the church
loses.
Conclusion
So you see. The challenge before us is daunting. To over come these
things will take nothing short of a Reformation, a true work of God. It will
take sobriety and clear mindedness. Strong leaders and supportive members.
Each will need to do his or her part. Next month we will look at what the
Lutheran Church has done to make matters all the worse. In the meantime
dwell on this.
1 Peter 1:13 "Therefore, gird your minds for action, keep sober in
spirit, fix your hope completely on the grace to be brought to you at the
revelation of Jesus Christ."